Israel has a right to kill Hamas voters, suggests President of NY Rabbis

29th Aug 2014

[Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner challenged the Fourth Geneva Convention when he claimed that Israel has a right to kill any Palestinian who voted for Hamas]

Elham Asaad Buaras

President of the New York Board of Rabbis caused a storm last month when he claimed that Israel has a right to kill any Palestinian who voted for Hamas.

Speaking at a pro-Israel rally in New York on July 28, Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner challenged the Fourth Geneva Convention and labelled everyone who voted for Hamas a combatant.

“When you are part of an election process that asks for a terrorist organisation which proclaims in word and indeed that their primary objective is to destroy their neighbouring  country and not to build schools or commerce or jobs, you are complicit and you are not a civilian casualty. ”

Kirshner also claimed the Israeli army is “the most moral army in the history of civilization.” He ended his remarks with the word, Amen.

Kirshner also suggested Palestinians who had failed “to heed the pamphlets, the phone calls, the text messages and the warning shots telling you to evacuate a building” are not collateral damage.”

Thane Rosenbaum, a legal scholar, wrote similarly in the Wall Street Journal on July 23: “You forfeit your right to be called civilians when you freely elect members of a terrorist organization as statesmen.”

The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) blasted Kirshner’s stance. Director of CAIR-NY Operations, Sadyia Khalique, said, “It is unconscionable for any American religious leader to designate hundreds of thousands of civilians as ‘combatants’ who deserve to be killed using weapons paid for by American taxpayers.”

“In New York, we don’t tolerate hateful violent rhetoric and call on responsible leaders in the New Jersey and New York Jewish communities to repudiate this apparent call for violence.”

Rosenbaum’s and Kirshner’s arguments have been widely lambasted. James Downie of the Washington Post said, “The claim that voting for a government takes away someone’s status as a noncombatant would be ludicrous if applied to all populations in all conflicts equally.

Such an attitude would at the very least contradict Article 33 of the Fourth Geneva Convention: ‘No protected person may be punished for an offense he or she has not personally committed.’ It also probably would up end much of the traditional framework protecting anyone not carrying weapons in war zones across the globe.”

Many critics including Demos think-tank’s Matt Bruenig have pointed out the chilling similarity between Rosenbaum’s and Kirshner’s words and Osama bin Laden’s rationale behind the 9/11 terror attacks.

“In his effort to wish away the civilian atrocities in Gaza, Rosenbaum has inadvertently made the argument of a terrorist,” wrote Bruenig.

Bruenig points out that a year after the 9/11 attacks bin Laden wrote a open letter explaining American civilians are legitimate targets in the al-Qa’ida attack as they have voted for governments who support oppression: “…the American people are the ones who choose their government by way of their own free will; a choice which stems from their agreement to its policies. Thus the American people have chosen, consented to, and affirmed their support for the Israeli oppression of the Palestinians, the occupation and usurpation of their land, and its continuous killing, torture, punishment and expulsion of the Palestinians.”

One Response to “Israel has a right to kill Hamas voters, suggests President of NY Rabbis”

PaulSeptember 1, 2014

It’s foolish at the very least, for such a statement to be made, regardless of political affiliations. Furthermore, it is inflammatory at any time let alone right now. However, it is also important to recognise that while Israel is the more successful aggressor in the latest conflict, they are not the instigators as their action is somewhat retaliatory. It is imperative that peace talks continue within an air of mutual understanding, and willingness for compromise, for the sake of humanity. Nothing can be achieved by repeatedly dragging up the crimes or errors of anyone’s forefathers. The key to peace is already in the hands of both sides but they need to embrace the idea. Sadly this article emphasizes an individual’s lack of a desire for peace and implies that it is the voice of Israel. It could never be of any beneficial value.

Reply

Leave a Comment

What is 6 + 8 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)

Over 120 people attended a landmark conference on the media reporting of Islam and Muslims. It was held jointly by The Muslim News and Society of Editors in London on September 15.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence 2015 was held on March in London to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to the society.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence 2015 was held on March in London to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to the society.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence event is to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to society. Over 850 people from diverse background, Muslim and non-Muslim, attended the gala dinner.

Latest Tweets