Clegg defends use of counter terrorism expert to investigate Muslim majority schools

25th Jul 2014
Clegg defends use of counter terrorism expert to investigate Muslim majority schools

Editor of The Muslim News, Ahmed J Versi , presses Deputy PM, Nick Clegg on the Government’s use of a couNter terrorism expert to investigate the Muslim majority schools (Photo: Sara Asaria/Muslim News)

Hamed Chapman

Deputy Prime Minister, Nick Clegg, has attempted to defend the Government’s controversial policy of tainting Birmingham schools with a brush of extremism and the use of a counter terrorism expert to investigate the Muslim majority schools.

In an exclusive interview with The Muslim News Editor, Ahmed J Versi, Clegg also switched the blame of the ensuing Islamophobic frenzy as being caused by the media rather than Education Secretary, Michael Gove, who initiated the Government’s interference with the support of Prime Minister, David Cameron, on the basis of a known forged document.

“If there are people in British Muslim communities who are anxious, fearful or, worse still, feel a bit intimidated by the tenor of this debate, I want them to know that I believe, and I think most people do, that they have as much right to their British identity as anybody else,” Clegg said.

“The vast majority of British Muslims believe in tolerance, equality before the law and mutual respect between faiths as much as anybody else. And so I think at a time of heightened anxiety like this, it is crucial that we work with the vast majority of British Muslims who want to promote values of mutual tolerance and respect, rather than run the risk of everyone feeling that they’re being painted into a corner. I think that it is very unhelpful and very unfair if people feel that they’re being tarred with the same brush.”

Clegg said that he was very keen to make this point “loud and clear” even though he supported the Government going ahead with putting five Birmingham schools under special measure, lining up four for takeover and taking 11 others to task despite Ofsted inspectors finding no evidence of alleged extremism nor of extremists taking over the schools as claimed by the ‘Trojan Horse’ conspiracy.

As Leader of the Liberal Democrats, the Deputy Prime Minister has his own separate issues with his Conservative partners over education policy. In particular, he does not believe in the freedom given to academies that come under direct Government control, who have no requirement to follow the national curriculum nor employ qualified teachers

“It is of great frustration for me, that the recommendation to ensure that all schools deliver a core curriculum, hasn’t been supported by the Conservatives and this Government. And I think that parents should be entitled to expect that their sons and daughters are being taught by qualified teachers, or by teachers who are seeking a qualification and that all children, across our country, are taught a core body of knowledge. And I think that it is wrong of the Conservatives to block that.”

He agreed that this was not the fault of Muslims but of Government policy yet still denied that the Birmingham schools where Muslim pupils were in the majority were being singled out. “All schools, where there is a sudden deterioration or a sudden concern, are susceptible to Ofsted inspections,” he claimed. “There are many, many schools which don’t make the headlines, that aren’t covered by the media, where Ofsted go in and make aggressive recommendations of change.”

Like in a recent official statement, Clegg expressed his deep regret about the whole media frenzy. “There’s a real danger that people feel that a whole community is being typecast, that a whole community is being stereotyped and I think that that’s deeply unfair. Many, many, many British Muslims are as British as anybody else.”

“There’s a real risk, with the way in which this issue has been portrayed, the language that has been deployed, the somewhat shrill way in which this has been portrayed in the media, and this has made many British Muslims feel that they’re being stereotyped, that they’re being typecast and this is wrong.”

The way to redress the Islamophobic tone, he suggested, was to “make sure that people are treated fairly, is to speak up in favour of the values that actually unite us.”

The Deputy Prime Minister refused to answer why the former head of counter terrorism had been sent by the Government to investigate the schools other than saying the circumstances were known under which he had been asked to go.

He denied that the Government believed that Muslim students at the schools were potentially extremists.

“No-one on the Government thinks that the little children, who deserve a good education here, are terrorists.” But he added “If the perception is that people are being typecast, that people are being pushed into the same corner, that is unfair, it is wrong and I strongly believe that we need to treat people with respect and on the merits of the case.”

Challenged why the Government tends to treat Muslims differently to other citizens looking at them through the lens of extremism and terrorism, Clegg said, “Extremism takes different forms” and insisted that the last meeting of the extremism task force was “all about the rise of anti-Muslim extremism.”

“This Government has taken unprecedented steps to attack and bear down on the EDL. That’s not a form of violent Muslim extremism, in fact it’s a form of, in many respects, violent anti-Muslim extremism. I abhor violent extremism of all kinds and I think it’s incredibly important that wherever violence of extremism takes root, it is treated with the same uncompromising approach and that is what we’re doing in this Government.”

One Response to “Clegg defends use of counter terrorism expert to investigate Muslim majority schools”

Iftikhar AhmadJuly 25, 2014

We like to be surrounded by our family and friends . We like to mix with people who have similar outlooks on life . We gravitate to those we feel we have something in common with . It’s taken the British centuries to put our enmities and tribal differences apart. They now only appear when we call other people’s football clubs nasty names. We can move around the country, send our children to different schools knowing that , apart from our accents , we all enjoy a similar education and upbringing. The problems arise when this general consensus is broken. The problems of a Northern Ireland show how having two divided communities and seperate education leads to problems . People may believe that isolation protects them from being ‘ contaminated ‘ by worldly influences, when all it does is make life difficult for their children .Ive seen so many young cult members who are totally lost when they leave their cult. All their friends , family and often employment was the only thing they know, and they find it almost impossible to get back into mainstream society . This fate applies to any group that tries to build walls to the society they live in

The residents of Birmingham ought to be able to sleep more easily tonight. Peter Clarke’s 129-page report into the city’s schools found no evidence of plots to indoctrinate, groom or recruit school pupils to an agenda of radicalisation, violent extremism or terrorism. This is also the key finding of the reports commissioned by Birmingham city council and Ofsted. The credibility of Ofsted has been shaken. Tim Brighouse, the former chief education officer of Birmingham, has criticised Ofsted for reporting uncorroborated accounts of past events. Furthermore, those accused were not questioned or asked to account for the allegations. Allegations of an Islamic takeover plot in Birmingham schools aren’t justified by the evidence – and the government response is way out of proportion

Unfortunately, a great deal of damage has been done by politicians who whip up hostility towards migrants coming to this country or towards a Muslim community that is very much part of Britain. Viewing the problems of governance through the prism of “culture wars”, with Birmingham schools as the battlefield, was bound to leave many casualties. The reality on the ground is a huge increase in bullying – including in one case Muslim children having a dog set on them – and being taunted with accusations of learning to make bombs at school. The impact of this stigma on a whole generation of the city’s Muslim students when applying to universities and jobs cannot be overstated.

Muslims don’t mix much with non-Muslims because of the deep vein of intolerance and outright racism that exists in British society. Imagine if you moved to Morocco, tried to start a life there and mix with the locals but the locals were openly and actively racist towards you and, however liberal you may be, you were portrayed as a war loving, capitalist right-wing bigot and feared by most? How long would you keep trying to ‘integrate’? You could equally say the same thing about non-Muslims and their experience with Muslims. Which is then seen by the other side as more intolerance and racism. And so the cycle goes on.
The funny thing is that Park View could just set themselves up as a faith school, and continue all of these practices, and nobody would bat an eye. Everything described in this report is fairly common at faith schools up and down the country, including Muslim, Catholic, and Orthodox Jewish schools. If you are really concerned about the influence of ‘radical’ views in schools, then you should be opposed to all faith schools. But, that’s not the view of this government. They have enthusiastically supported faith schools.


Leave a Comment

What is 9 + 11 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)

Over 120 people attended a landmark conference on the media reporting of Islam and Muslims. It was held jointly by The Muslim News and Society of Editors in London on September 15.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence 2015 was held on March in London to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to the society.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence 2015 was held on March in London to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to the society.

The Muslim News Awards for Excellence event is to acknowledge British Muslim and non-Muslim contributions to society. Over 850 people from diverse background, Muslim and non-Muslim, attended the gala dinner.

Latest Tweets